Vagueness is killing the church

The directions to the first-time boat owner said: “Be sure that the trailer wheels get into the water.” The result of his attempt is recorded...

I love that because that is what I see in the church all the time. Vagueness is killing the church. Vague ideas…vague mission statements...vague theology with extremely vague applications. It all sounds good and has nice imagery like love, grace, light, hope and god. But, my problem as a leader is that there is rarely any TRACTION under it all. It puts us in the ballpark, but we just can’t play the game with the vague concepts we throw around.

I know that almost every leader hopes that their ministry makes a difference. Every parent I know hopes that their kids turn out ok. Every church I know hopes that their programs help people. But, I want to remind you of an important truth: “HOPE IS NOT A STRATEGY.” God bless you for the feeling, but hope will only carry you so far.

Effective leadership is not vague. It is practical and connected to a context. You are a leader in a real situation with real people. Theory will not cut it, but we fall back on generalities too often. Churches rely on words that vaguely tell the story of God, but don’t unpack it for their people…don’t connect it to the real world….and don’t wrestle with specific applications.

For some it is because we don’t want to be “legalistic” and tell people what they must do. So, we resist any application and keep it vague so that it will sound good. For others, it is too avoid getting messy with the real world, so we keep the truth at a distance. Whatever the reason, we must realize the vagueness misses the point.

There simply is no passion in vagueness. There is no application in vagueness. And, we lose Jesus in vagueness.

If we are in youth ministry leadership, we are coming alongside real people with real issues who want to find out if a real God is anywhere to be found. A vague idea—even if it has a bible verse attached—is not going to be helpful. Our role is to have core values that we can articulate to young people and their parents. Our role calls us to teach things in ways that people can understand…and that they can apply into their lives.

It is a high calling—and the reason why I write this blog. I want leaders who are passionate about youth ministry, clear about their mission, and strategic about their context. There is much to learn.

Work on clarity so that the right wheels go in the water.

To Save a Life

Youth ministry is more than being fun with kids, running a few cool events and using “The Message” translation of the Bible!! In today’s world, it includes coming alongside of ever-increasing numbers of teenagers who are at-risk and struggling with life. It is real and raw in youth ministry today.

If you are one of the weird adults who wants to be a godly, caring presence in the lives of teenagers…you will be thrown into issues that can be scary and overwhelming. The upcoming movie “To Save a Life” will address many of these issues—and may give you and your ministry a chance to have some deep conversations. That sounds good, but the problem is—they may be honest conversations about real life and real pain.

Without giving you a counseling curriculum, I wanted to give you a few ideas on how you can go from Good Intentions to Helpful Actions. We teach a 3 day COUNSEL class at Youth Leadership—and I have learned a lot from my co-teacher, Dr. Kevin Harrington. Much of what I will share is stolen or adapted from him!! If you or your volunteers come alongside of teenagers with only good intentions, you might be more dangerous than helpful. And having a bible verse doesn’t make you any better….sorry.

So, here are few ideas to add to your good intentions:

Know why you are there.
Be real clear on what your role is when you talk to kids. Get rid of any focus on fixing the problem, controlling their response or solving the tension they are feeling.
Your job is to love them…listen to them…stay with them. To do more is usually to help US feel better—and that is NOT why you are there.
So, when a teen says “My parents are getting a divorce”, you need to be clear about what your role is. Don’t jump to the bible right away—don’t try to fix it or give an easy answer.

Name it
Naming the issue at hand is incredibly healing. It doesn’t fix it, but it gets it out in the open. Caring for another person is getting them to name the issue, struggle, concern or fear. It is also a possibility that your role is to help name it for them.

Without making caring into a formula, it is crucial that you are able to be focused. In the first few minutes ask some variation of this question: “What brought you here to talk to me?” or, “What are you hoping will happen because we are talking?”
Other questions that will help you name it—or get them to name it.
i. “How can I be most helpful today?”
ii. “Tell me what is happening”

Know your limits
Every person has limits—emotional, skills and time. A caring person must KNOW these and ADMIT these. If you have 15 minutes...be clear about that and give them a good 15 minutes. Don’t try to be a therapist—you aren’t that good, so admit it.

Helpful people don’t try to do too much. Be honest with your skill limits. “Boy, this sounds really tough—and that is way over my head. I can do this (name it), but it sure sounds like we should find someone who can get you the help you really need right now.”

Look beyond behaviors
A big mistake is getting stuck on behaviors and just trying to get kids to STOP this or START this. Behaviors are important…but the real issue is always below the surface of behaviors.
Let behaviors be a starting point, but go to the Injury or Hurt that resides below the surface. What is the pain they feel? Where is the rejection, loss, etc?

The hardest work—and the most healing—is to then talk about their INTERPRETATION of the hurt. How do they see it through THEIR eyes? If you look hard enough, it almost always comes back to a feeling of being worthless, unlovable or deficient in some way. For many kids, the things that are happening prove that there is something wrong with them. OUR JOB is to listen to this, love them in Jesus name, and not try to fix it right away.

For example: A kid comes to you and says “I struggle with cutting”. It is NOT your job to get them to stop—that is only focusing on behaviors. Instead, get them to talk about the issues. Get curious—“what makes you feel like you need to cut? How does that work for you?” Listen for the hurts and their interpretation of the hurts in their life.

Make the circle bigger
No matter who you are, you should be asking, “Who else should be involved in this?” This is both a referral issue, but it is most importantly a caring issue. Who else has the young person told? Who is in his/her support network? What resources would be helpful to them?
Don’t ever do this caring alone. Get support from others—insight from others—and perspective from others. Your “secret” relationship is not only dangerous; it simply is unhelpful to the person.

Saving a life is God’s job—but being a caring person when a person is hurting can be a powerful ministry. You and your volunteers can do that if they stay focused, admit their limits, increase their clarity, look beyond behaviors and make the circle bigger. There is much more to this, but go ahead…start the conversation. Care enough to get involved in the messy reality of kid’s lives—and pray that God would use you to save a life.

Peace in Christ,
Tiger

Welcome

Welcome to my blog.

For the three of you reading this—I want to say thank you for joining me. I have now entered the blogosphere—and I do so both reluctantly and with some excitement.

I am an aging youth worker—I still love youth ministry—love the crazy world of teenagers—and love those of you who are weird enough to be in the middle of all of this. This blog will be a place for me to share thoughts, reflections and ideas with you. It will be a place for me to wonder with you about the mysteries and struggles of leadership. For some reason, God has placed me in youth and family ministry leadership since my early days in college. I have learned a lot—and made A LOT of mistakes.

Let me say something as I start. I am hesitant about this—and have resisted the efforts of my staff to make this a reality many months—because I have asked this question one too many times:

“Does the world need one more egotistical person who really thinks their ideas need to be heard?”

It causes me to reflect and wonder. We all talk SO much…we say SO much..we update our status on facebook….we twitter…we preach and teach. And there can be an addiction to the “platform.” If we are honest…we all know this about leadership. We have a platform—verbal or written. And we start to hear ourselves, and we start to believe our own press releases. I want to be careful about that here.

This blog is sub-titled: “Reflections of an imperfect youth worker.” That is me. That is my reality. That is my press release to you.

Yes, I am a leader, teacher, speaker and author. I am the President of an organization called Youth Leadership, have taught at seminaries and I have been called an “expert” at times. My press releases highlight my successes.

It’s all good. And mostly true. But here—in this technological community—I will wonder about leadership. Honest leadership. Real people. Imperfect realities. And, I will not inflate or deflect…but will do my best to honestly think about the issues involved in youth ministry leadership.

So, I enter the blogosphere. If you choose to come along—welcome. I invite your comments and thoughts as we journey together.

Peace in Christ, Tiger